Get the Complate
AIP Food List...

Sign up to the newsletter and receive
your FREE Guide!

100% privacy, no spam & weekly email support.
Don't like it? Unsub in a click!

Paleo Valentine’s Day Cookies (GF, DF & AIP)

This post may contain affiliate links.
In order to keep this website up and running, my posts may contain affiliate links, meaning that if you purchase something from one of my links, I will receive a small percentage at no additional cost to you. Sometimes you'll also find sponsored posts, meaning that I may receive monetary compensation or other types or remuneration for products or services I endorse, recommend and/or link to. Trust that I only ever recommend products that I truly love and believe in. Thanks for your support!!
Paleo Valentine’s Day Cookies (GF, DF & AIP)

Whether you are gluten intolerant, have an issue with grains and dairy or are following the Auto Immune Protocol (AIP), the one thing you all have in common is that you all deserve to celebrate love with a treat… and these Paleo Valentine’s Day Cookies are your best bet to satisfy every kind of food intolerance!

Paleo Valentines Cookies

Now, I know you’ll be asking me: if these are paleo Valentine’s Day cookies, why the heck did you decorate them with poker symbols?!?

Well, the answer is that these specific Valentine’s Day cookies are the paleo treat I made for Alec, whom, as you might know, is a professional poker player… So why only carving out hearts when I can play around with chocolate covered spades, clubs and diamonds?

And this is what I invite you to do too: think about a passion or a characteristic that can apply to your love, and use that to personalize your paleo Valentine’s cookie recipe too!

Paleo Valentines Cookies

Another cool thing about these cookies is that they are really fun to make! I loved dipping my tiny painting brush into melted chocolate and decorating my Valentine’s treat with a yummy layer.

If you are on the AIP and haven’t reintroduced cacao yet, you can use my recipe for carob chocolate, which is a delicious alternative.

And if you just want to be quick, and got overwhelmed when you read the words “painting brush” (!!!), don’t worry, you can absolutely go the easier route and simply dip part of your paleo Valentine’s cookies into melted chocolate.


As per the best way to melt chocolate and have it be perfectly smooth and liquid, here’s a little secret that my Dad taught me: ”

Don’t place your chocolate directly over the burner. Simply turn on the stove, place your chocolate in a ceramic cup and leave this close to the burner enough to feel the heat and slowly start melting”.

And if you want to make your chocolate layer even more indulgent, add a few drops of coconut milk and Manuka honey in it!!

Paleo Valentine's Day Cookies (GF, DF & AIP)





No. of


    For the Cookies:

For the Toppings:

  1. Preheat the oven to 350 F.
  2. In a mixing bowl combine tigernut flour and arrowroot and mix well.
  3. Add in the maca powder and all the remaining wet ingredients and knead well with your hands until you get a nice and compact ball of dough.
  4. Helping yourself with a rolling pin, roll down the dough on a wooden board (or, if you don’t have it, you can simply place a sheet of parchment paper on the table) until ¼ of an inch thick.
  5. Using a heart-shaped cookie cutter, cut out your paleo Valentine’s cookies, place them on a baking pan lined with parchment paper and bake for 15 minutes.
  6. Let them cool and, when ready, decorate them with some melted chocolate (I used a little painting brush to decorate mine).
  7. Lastly, sprinkle some lemon zest and pomegranate powder on top and serve to your love!

I an sure you guys are going this recipe and I can’t wait to hear how you personalized these paleo Valentine’s Day cookies for the person you love… so make sure to let me know in a comment and share some photos on your social media!

And like always, I am always grateful when you click “share” and show my recipes to your family and friends!

Have the Best Valentine’s Day!! Ambra

Enter your email for "The 10 Day AIP Breakfast Plan" ... FREE!

Paleo Valentines Cookies
Paleo Valentine’s Day Cookies (GF, DF & AIP)

This recipe was featured on the Phoenix Helix Recipe Roundtable

Sharing is caring!

Get Your FREE
“10 Day AIP
Breakfast Plan”!

Subscribe to the newsletter and receive
your FREE Guide!

100% privacy, no spam & weekly email support.
Don't like it? Unsub in a click!
Ambra Torelli
Born and raised in Italy, Ambra visited over 20 countries and now she divides her time in between Italy and the US, where her husband is from and where she moved in 2011 work as university professor of Italian Literature. She writes about food, travel and things that inspire her! more about ambra

You May Also Like


  • Sylph February 11, 2017 2:50 pm

    This looks like another wonderful recipe to try Ambra. Cookies for your love. I am going to have to think how to personalize mine for my hubby!

    • ambra February 11, 2017 10:06 pm

      Sylph, thanks so much dear!! Can’t see what you come up with!!

Leave a Reply